TROY MICR Toner vs Remanufactured MICR Toner

Quick answer: If your printer is a TROY-secured MICR printer, use the toner TROY specifies for it. If you print checks on a standard HP LaserJet, you can use a remanufactured MICR cartridge matched to the cartridge number already in the printer. Laser Barn carries those, up to 40% less than OEM. Either way, print a test batch and have your bank run it through its reader before a live payroll or vendor run.

What TROY is

TROY Group makes MICR printers, MICR toner, and check-security software. Its MICR Toner Secure line is built for HP-based printers and adds a security feature: a red dye that shows up if someone tries to chemically wash the check. TROY-secured printers can also require TROY toner. Those are TROY's features. We don't claim them for our cartridges.

What remanufactured MICR toner is

A remanufactured MICR cartridge is an HP cartridge shell that has been cleaned, rebuilt, filled with magnetic (MICR) toner, and tested. It goes in the same slot as the regular cartridge, and the cartridge number is the same (58A, 148A, 26A, and so on). The magnetic toner is what lets a bank's reader see the routing, account, and check-number line at the bottom of the check (the E-13B MICR line).

Side by side

TROY MICR Toner Secure Laser Barn remanufactured MICR
Prints a magnetic E-13B MICR line Yes Yes
Fits standard HP LaserJet check printers Yes Yes, matched by HP cartridge number
Required for TROY-secured MICR printers Often, so follow TROY's spec Not for TROY-locked printers
Anti-washing red dye Yes (TROY feature) No
Price See TROY or your dealer Up to 40% less than OEM
Testing Test with your bank 100% post-tested before it ships. Test with your bank too.

Does HP require TROY toner?

HP has long pointed check printers to TROY for MICR, and some HP documents name TROY. That's a recommendation for MICR printing, and it doesn't stop a standard HP LaserJet from taking a MICR cartridge with the same cartridge number. What the bank cares about is whether the MICR line reads. Laser Barn is not endorsed by HP or TROY.

When TROY is the better pick

  • You run a TROY-secured printer or TROY check software that expects TROY toner.
  • You want TROY's anti-washing dye feature on every check.
  • Your bank or auditor has told you in writing to use a specific brand.

When remanufactured MICR makes sense

  • You print checks on a standard HP LaserJet (M404/M428, 4001/4101, M402/M426, M507/M528, M607–M609 and others).
  • You print payroll, vendor, or client checks in-house and want to cut toner cost.
  • You'll run a test batch with your bank first.

Common HP MICR cartridges we carry

Printer Cartridge number Our MICR cartridge Price* OEM-rated yield
HP LaserJet Pro M404 / MFP M428 58A (CF258A) 58A MICR $155.99 about 3,000 pages
HP LaserJet Pro M404 / MFP M428 58X (CF258X) 58X MICR $199.99 about 10,000 pages
HP LaserJet Pro 4001 / MFP 4101 148A (W1480A) 148A MICR $145.99 about 2,900 pages
HP LaserJet Pro 4001 / MFP 4101 148X (W1480X) 148X MICR $186.99 about 9,500 pages
HP LaserJet Pro M402 / MFP M426 26A (CF226A) 26A MICR $116.99 about 3,100 pages

*Prices as of Nov 15, 2026. Yields are the OEM-rated page counts for the matching HP cartridge (ISO/IEC 19752 where that is confirmed on the product page).

Printer not listed? Use the MICR toner printer finder, or browse all MICR toner.

Buying for a specific kind of office?

See MICR toner for CPA, tax and payroll offices, MICR toner for check printers and community banks, or printing your own checks in-house. Questions? Call 864-365-6462 or email info@laser-barn.com.

FAQ

Do I need TROY MICR toner to print checks?

Not on a standard HP printer. You need magnetic MICR toner in a cartridge that matches your printer. TROY is one brand of MICR toner. Remanufactured MICR matched to the same HP cartridge number is another. If your printer is TROY-secured, use the toner TROY specifies. Either way, have your bank test a batch first.

Is remanufactured MICR toner the same as TROY?

No. Both print a magnetic E-13B MICR line, but TROY MICR Toner Secure adds TROY features such as a red anti-washing dye and works with TROY-secured printers. Laser Barn remanufactured MICR is matched to the HP cartridge number and costs up to 40% less than OEM. It is not TROY-certified and is not endorsed by HP or TROY.

Does HP require TROY toner for MICR printing?

HP has recommended TROY for MICR printing and some HP documents name TROY, but a standard HP printer takes a MICR cartridge with the same cartridge number as its regular toner. What matters to the bank is that the MICR line reads, so run a test batch.

Will my bank accept checks printed with remanufactured MICR toner?

Banks judge the MICR line, not the toner brand. Print a test batch on your normal check stock and ask your bank to run it through its reader before you print a live run. We can't promise any bank's acceptance in advance.

How much less does remanufactured MICR cost?

Up to 40% less than OEM. Current prices are on each product page. For example, the 58A MICR for HP M404/M428 printers was $155.99 on Nov 15, 2026.

Questions about toner for your office or lab?