HP 89A vs 89X Toner (and 89Y)

Which should you buy? If you print often, the 89X holds more toner and usually means fewer changes. If you print only occasionally, the 89A costs less upfront. Compare yield and cost per page in the table below — we only list a page count when the product page states one. We also carry a 89Y option if you print at even higher volume. Every remanufactured cartridge is 100% post-tested and priced at up to 40% less than OEM.

We drop ship nationwide. There is no local pickup.

HP Original is the Gold Standard. We also carry remanufactured cartridges that replace the OEM cartridge number in the product title.

89A vs 89X at a glance

Cost per page uses the yield stated on each product page and our current price. If a page count is not listed on the product page, we do not estimate one.

Which printers do they fit?

Both the 89A and 89X are listed for the same HP printers, including HP LaserJet Enterprise Flow MFP M528C, HP LaserJet Managed Flow MFP E52645C, HP LaserJet Enterprise MFP M528DN, HP LaserJet Enterprise M507DNG, HP LaserJet Enterprise M507DN, HP LaserJet Managed E50145DN, MFP E52645DN, M507N, M507X, M528F, and M528Z. Match the cartridge number on your empty cartridge to the product title before you order.

Our remanufactured and compatible options

We carry the 89A and 89X as remanufactured cartridges, all 100% post-tested, at up to 40% less than OEM:

HP 89A black, new chip · HP 89A black, reused OEM chip · HP 89X black, new chip · HP 89X black, reused OEM chip · HP 89Y black, new chip · HP 89Y black, reused OEM chip

Related pages

Printer guides: HP Enterprise M507; HP Enterprise MFP M528. Browse the series collection: HP 89A and 89X Toner.

Frequently asked questions

Should I buy the 89A or the 89X?

If you print often, the 89X usually means fewer changes. If you print only occasionally, the 89A costs less upfront. Confirm the yield on the product page — we only publish a page count when that page states one.

Do the 89A and 89X fit the same printers?

Yes. Both are listed for the same HP printers. Match the cartridge number on your empty cartridge to the product title and confirm your exact model on the product page.

How is yield listed here?

Yield is copied from each product page. If that page confirms an ISO figure, we say so. Otherwise we say “about X pages,” or “see product page” when no page count is listed.

Is this an OEM HP cartridge?

No. HP Original is the Gold Standard. The cartridges linked here are remanufactured replacements for the OEM cartridge number in the product title. Every cartridge is 100% post-tested and priced at up to 40% less than OEM.

Do you offer local pickup?

No. Every order is drop shipped, and we ship nationwide with free ground shipping.